Overconfidence Bias: Are You as Sure as You Think?

Overconfidence Bias: Why Most of Us Think We Are Above-Average With Money

Table of Contents

Short answer: Overconfidence bias is believing we know more, or will do better, than we actually do. Most drivers rate themselves above average, and most people feel sure about money answers they get wrong. In finance it shows up as frequent trading, borrowing at the top of what we can repay and skipping insurance. The fix is to measure your accuracy and plan with a margin.

Calibration: confidence vs accuracy

Good calibration means that when you are 90% sure, you are right about 90% of the time. Many people are right far less often than their confidence suggests. The Money Brain Test asks five true-or-false money questions with a confidence rating each, then compares the two.

Where it costs money

  • Trading too often. Studies of retail investors find that those who trade most tend to earn less after costs.
  • Stretching the EMI. Assuming income will rise and nothing will go wrong leads to EMIs that leave no room for surprises.
  • Underinsuring. “It won’t happen to me” leaves families exposed to a single hospital bill.
  • Ignoring the fine print. Feeling sure about a product’s terms without reading the Key Fact Statement.

How to keep confidence honest

  1. Keep a decision log. Note what you expected and check back in six months.
  2. Plan for a bad month. Keep total EMIs comfortably within your take-home pay, with an emergency fund for three to six months.
  3. Use a pre-mortem. Before a big decision, imagine it went wrong and list why.
  4. Test yourself. A weekly round of Money Points shows where your confidence matches your knowledge, because you stake more coins on what you feel sure of.

Test your own money brain

Take the 4-minute Money Brain Test, which measures this and seven other biases, or play this week’s Money Points game. More in Money Mind.

Frequently asked questions

What is overconfidence bias in finance?

Overestimating your knowledge or ability, which can lead to frequent trading, too much borrowing or too little insurance.

How can I tell if I am overconfident?

Rate your confidence on questions or predictions and track how often you are right. If you are right less often than you expected, you are overconfident.

Is confidence bad for money decisions?

No. Confidence helps you act. The problem is confidence that is not matched by accuracy, so check it and leave a safety margin.

Written by the Omozing Credit Team, whose members include IIT and IIM alumni. Reviewed for accuracy by our credit and compliance team. For education only; not financial advice.